It’s Pie Season, New Jersey! Which Thanksgiving Pie Is #1 In Your Home?

The Most Popular Thanksgiving Pies Across America

It's almost that time of year to indulge in the most delicious pies of the season! You can almost smell them baking!

If you're on pie patrol this Thanksgiving, which one will you bring?

Get our free mobile app

You know that pie that everyone at the table looks forward to and will totally miss if you don't show up with it.

For me, it's the apple pie my aunt brings every year. It's SO good! And there will definitely be looks of disappointment if it isn't on the dining room table this year!

What's your favorite pie, New Jersey?

Read More: Craving Something Sweet? This Ocean County Candy Store Has It All

Food & Wine Magazine is out with the most popular pies in America.

Instacart’s 2024 Thanksgiving data shows there's one pie that's the most-ordered dessert nationwide, with orders increasing more than 2,000% the day before the holiday.

The Top Pie In The Country

1. Pumpkin Pie

2. Apple Pie

3. Pecan Pie

4. Sweet Potato Pie

5. Cherry Pie

6. Berry Pie

7. Key Lime Pie

8. Cream Pie

9. Peach Pie

10. Peanut Butter Pie

Do you agree?

More specifically, the most popular pie in New Jersey is cream pie, which came in 8th overall throughout the county.

My favorite is apple pie! I like it more than pumpkin and definitely more than cream pie!

Check out the shops below where you can find the most delicious pies this holiday season!