There may soon be another vacant space inside a shopping mall in Mays Landing. Gossip is swirling that American Eagle may be leaving.


Sorry we are closed sign board hanging on a door of cafe

American Eagle in Mays Landing is reportedly officially closed as of Sunday, January 21, 2024.

American Eagle, located on the upper level of Hamilton Mall in Mays Landing, occupies quite a large space.

Hamilton Mall in Mays Landing, NJ
Google Maps

But come February, the store could be empty.

The speculation is based on an unconfirmed report, but here's what I've heard.

An employee of the location, who wished to remain anonymous, told me over New Year's weekend that she's in the process of looking for another job because she and other employees were recently informed that American Eagle inside Hamilton Mall has not renewed its lease and will close at the end of January.

If that ends up being accurate, American Eagle, best known for its jeans and hoodies, will join other retailers who've either closed at Hamilton Mall in recent years or gone out of business entirely, like Charlotte Russe.

American Eagles Clothing Store
Getty Images

Garage, Francesca's, and Loft departed in years past, and department stores like Sears and JCPenny have disappeared from the mall, leaving only Macy's.

If American Eagle indeed departs Mays Landing, devotees will have to travel to Tanger Outlets in Atlantic City or Deptford Mall locally to see American Eagle merchandise in person, or order online.

94.3 The Point logo
Get our free mobile app

I reached out to American Eagle's corporate office, AEO Management Co., looking for confirmation about the future of the Mays Landing location but had not received a response by the time I published this story.

If you know anything for certain, feel free to reach out.

Exclusive Pictures: Do You Remember New Jersey's Echelon Mall?

Once upon a time, the Echelon Mall in Voorhees was a premier shopping destination. Let's go back in time and remember what it was like in all its glory.

Gallery Credit: Heather DeLuca

42 Stores and Restaurants Shoppers Would Love to See at Cumberland Mall in Vineland, NJ

Even as developed as Cumberland Mall in Vineland, New Jersey and its surrounding area may be, residents have big opinions on what its missing, and what would bring them shopping more often.

Gallery Credit: Heather DeLuca