This Hidden NJ Spot Serves One of the Best Lobster Rolls in America

Why Lobster Rolls Are So Popular

There’s something about biting into a lobster roll that just screams summer. It’s one of those meals that instantly puts you in a better mood. Maybe it’s the buttery bun, or the fact that it feels fancy even when it’s served out of a food truck.

Some people get weirdly passionate about how a lobster roll should be made. Some folks swear by the cold version with mayo, while others will die on the hill of warm, buttery lobster tossed in drawn butter. That would be me. Both sides have a point, but honestly, if it’s fresh lobster and a perfectly toasted bun, it’s going to be delicious either way.

Where to Find the Best Lobster Rolls In NJ

You don’t need to be in Maine to find a good lobster roll, but if you ever get the chance to eat one there, don’t miss it. Still, plenty of spots in New Jersey are serving up rolls that’ll make you do a little happy dance. Look for the ones that don’t skimp on the lobster. Nobody wants a sandwich filled with more lettuce than meat.

Also, a side note: the bun matters more than people think. A classic New England split-top, grilled in butter until golden, makes all the difference. It’s like the unsung hero of the whole thing.

Pair it with some kettle chips or fries, a squeeze of lemon, maybe a little pickle on the side, and you’re set. It's the kind of meal that makes you want to slow down, sit outside, and pretend you don’t have a million things on your to-do list.

READ MORE: The Best Italian Bakery is Hiding in Plain Sight Here in NJ

Yelp! has identified the best lobster rolls in every state based on user reviews.

The award for NJ goes to a place that locals know is legit, but outside of Ocean County, you may not have ever heard of Point Pleasant Beach's Atlantic Offshore Fishery. This hidden gem at the Shore does seafood right. You would think that most restaurants at the beach would know that they must serve the freshest of seafood, but you'd be surprised. After you sample the best lobster roll of your life, try Atlantic Offshore Fishery's sushi. Oh my.

👇Looking for more excellent seafood spots to try? Keep scrolling!👇