Have You Been To New Jersey’s Best Underrated Restaurant?

We love many things in New Jersey, but we believe our top passion is trying as many great Garden State restaurants as we can.

New Jersey has a pretty great food scene that we are very lucky to have.

I find myself being a creature of habit and revisiting my reliable favorites, but recently I decided to make it my mission to get out of my comfort zone and test out something new.

If you're like me and are on a quest to discover that amazing restaurant that you may have never heard of, we think we can help.

Get our free mobile app

We stumbled upon a list of the most underrated restaurants in each state and one of those undiscovered/underrated restaurants is right here in the Garden State.

Of course, this restaurant is far from undiscovered by its loyal patrons, but it has been named the most underrated restaurant in the state by Spoon University.

You'll love this restaurant's story as much as you'll love its food.

New Jersey's Best Underrated Restaurant

Congratulations to Sammy's Ye Old Cider Mill in Mendham for being named the most underrated restaurant in all of New Jersey.

This great restaurant has an amazing history.

They started as a speakeasy way back in the 1920s, known as Sammy's Cider Mill, and now a century later, it's a beloved steakhouse.

If you want to discover the most underrated restaurant in New Jersey for yourself, it's located at 353 Mendham Road West (Route 24) in Mendham.

While you're there, make sure you order the Shrimp Scampi. It is amazing and is an absolute crowd favorite.

If you're looking to find other amazing restaurants in New Jersey, the Anthony Bourdain Trail should be on your bucket list.