Food Experts Pick New Jersey’s Best Italian Restaurant For 2025

Food experts have chosen the best Italian restaurant in New Jersey. Let's see if you agree.

There can be no more controversial choice each year in Garden State than the one named our best Italian restaurant.

Which Italian Restaurant Is New Jersey's Best For 2025?

It doesn't matter which Italian restaurant the experts choose, there will be pushback from every corner of the state.

And there's good reason for it. New Jersey may be home to the best Italian restaurants in America, so choosing one that rises above the rest is a daunting task and one we are glad we didn't have to tackle.

That's because the folks at 5 Reasons To Visit did it for us. They traveled the country to find the best Italian restaurant in each state for 2025, and the results are in.

Naming New Jersey's Top Italian Restaurant Is Bound To Spark Debate

Let the debate begin. These experts chose an amazing Rutherford Italian restaurant as the top spot in the Garden State for 2025.

Read More: This Is New Jersey's Best Seafood Restaurant

Have you ever been to a place called Fiorentini Italian? If not, it may be time to make plans to get there.

This incredible Italian eatery is the restaurant that rose above all the other great Italian restaurants in our state to be named the best by these experts.

An Incredible Restaurant In Rutherford Has Been Named The Best For 2025

We like to look at these choices as more options for our bucket list, not necessarily a need for a debate or battle.

Get our free mobile app

There's plenty of room for all of our favorite New Jersey Italian restaurants and a trip to Rutherford, right?