No harm no fowl. According to an update given by the Plumsted Police Department on their Facebook page, the stolen goose has been found and returned.

"The missing goose has been located and successfully returned. We would like to thank our followers for the excellent detective work!"

The goose statue was stolen out of the New Egypt Wawa around 1:40a by two unidentified females. It didn't take long for this wild goose chase to end. 

Plumsted Police Department Facebook Page