Over in the northern end of Monmouth County, people in the Matawan/Aberdeen area are passionate about their pizza! In fact, they love their favorite pizza places so much that four out of the 5 practically tied...with one running away with the most votes for Favorite Pizza at the Bayshore.

I think I need to personally do a blind taste-test!

Here are the results, from fifth to first, for Favorite Pizza at the Bayshore:

Enter your number to get our free mobile app