New Jersey’s Legendary Top 5 Restaurants

New Jersey residents have spoken and chosen the top 5 restaurants in the Garden State. How many have you been to?

It's hard to narrow down the best restaurants in New Jersey because we have so many great ones, but when we asked for your choices on several social media platforms, you came up with some great answers.

New Jersey Residents Vote On The State's Best Restaurant

No one knows the great restaurants of New Jersey more than Garden State residents, so we looked at your opinions, counted up the votes, and came up with the list of the 5 best restaurants in New Jersey for 2025.

The great news is that most regions of the state are represented on the list, and let's remember, there's no way to show love to all the great Garden State restaurants on a top 5 list.

Many great eateries had to be left off the list, but that doesn't mean we don't love them all, because we do.

Here Are The Top 5 New Jersey Restaurants

So, here is the top 5 list of the best restaurants in New Jersey, according to the votes of state residents. We hope your favorite made the list.

#5 The Frog & The Peach, New Brunswick - This amazing restaurant has been around since the early '80s. It has a great history and amazing food.

#4 Scarborough Fair, Sea Girt - One of the most romantic restaurants in the state. It's an experience you'll never forget

Read More: New Jersey's Best Italian Restaurant

#3 Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant, Cape May - When you visit the legendary town of Cape May, it's not complete without a great meal at Peter Shields.

#2 The Chart House, Weehawkin - The food is amazing, and the breathtaking view is one of the most amazing things you'll ever experience.

Get our free mobile app

#1 The Saddle River Inn, Saddle River - Your choice for the best restaurant in New Jersey for 2025, and it's a great selection.

These amazing restaurants are just the tip of the iceberg in New Jersey. Enjoy them all with the ones you love.